Featured Article
Article Title
Time and Care: A Qualitative Exploration of Prisoners’ Perceptions of Trauma-Informed Care in Women’s Prisons
Authors
Jude Kelman; Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience, King’s College, London, UK; His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS), London, UK
Laura Palmer; Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience, King’s College, London, UK
Rachael Gribble; Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience, King’s College, London, UK
Deirdre MacManus; Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience, King’s College, London, UK
Abstract
Keywords
Summary of Research
Kelman et al. (2024) explored incarcerated women’s experiences of trauma-informed care (TIC) within women’s prisons in England, where correctional institutions have been working toward providing trauma-informed and responsive care due to the high prevalence of psychological trauma among incarcerated women. The authors distinguished between trauma-informed services, “where staff are trained to understand trauma and its impacts,” and trauma-responsive services, “where organizations and services have created a positive environment” and implemented practices to minimize retraumatization (p. 321). Although trauma-informed approaches have increasingly been adopted in correctional settings, “qualitative explorations of the way recipients experience services that aim to be trauma-informed and responsive” remain scarce (p. 322). The study sought to examine “the barriers and enablers to trauma-informed and responsive care as experienced by women in prison,” including “the perceived impact of staff trauma training” (p. 321). Specifically, the researchers explored how incarcerated women perceived the attitudes and behaviors of prison staff and whether trauma-informed training influenced their experiences of safety, trust, and care.
The researchers conducted a qualitative study involving 51 incarcerated women across three women’s prisons in England. Participants completed “one-to-one face-to-face interviews” using a semi-structured interview schedule exploring their “opinions about, and experiences of, barriers or enablers to the provision of TIC in prisons” (p. 323). Of the participants, 98% reported prior trauma, and 53% had previously experienced incarceration. Different recruitment strategies were used across the three prisons, including self-selection, convenience sampling, and systematic random sampling. During interviews, “the principles of TIC were first described to participants” to establish a shared understanding, and questions focused on experiences of safety, trust, and staff behavior (p. 323). Participants were also asked about their perceptions of the Becoming Trauma-Informed (BTI) staff training program. Interviews continued until “new information was no longer being identified,” and the researchers used “the six phases of inductive Thematic Analysis” to analyze the data, identify recurring patterns, and develop themes (p. 323).
The researchers identified three overarching themes: “time—a precious commodity, feeling cared for and trauma-informed staff training” (p. 324). Time was described as “a significant and precious commodity within prison,” with its availability acting as either an enabler or barrier to trauma-informed care (p. 324). Participants frequently described understaffing and competing demands as limiting opportunities for meaningful interactions with staff. Conversely, “the presence of time created chances for staff to make themselves available to interact with people in prison” (p. 325). Even ordinary conversations and gestures of kindness were meaningful, allowing participants to feel recognized as individuals rather than solely as prisoners. One participant described a positive interaction with an officer, stating, “I just felt like a human again” (p. 325). The researchers found that “feeling cared for appeared to have been at the core of what participants wanted from TIC in prison” (p. 325). Staff who demonstrated empathy, kindness, and understanding helped participants feel safe and develop trust, whereas dismissive, neglectful, or abusive behaviors undermined these experiences. Participants emphasized the importance of “being listened to more” and having staff who “see me as a person” (p. 326).
The third theme examined participants’ perceptions of trauma-informed staff training and its influence on staff attitudes and behaviors. Most participants were unaware that staff had received BTI training and “did not perceive it to have impacted their safety or care in prison” (p. 326). Many participants believed that the training had not meaningfully changed staff behavior, with one stating, “I didn’t even know they had trauma training. They’re not acting any differently” (p. 327). Some participants characterized the training as “a box-ticking exercise,” suggesting that staff attended without meaningfully incorporating the principles into their daily interactions (p. 327). Participants recommended involving incarcerated women in developing and delivering training, providing regular refresher courses, and recruiting staff with demonstrated empathy and caregiving abilities. The researchers emphasized that “the key enabler for participants to experience TIC was feeling cared for,” while the scarcity of time and negative staff behavior remained significant barriers (p. 328). Overall, participants viewed “wider systems, cultures and resources within the prisons” as more important to the provision of trauma-informed care than staff training alone (p. 328).
The findings highlight the importance of interpersonal relationships, empathy, and organizational support in providing trauma-informed care within correctional settings. The authors suggested that “training alone may be insufficient to counter the negative behavior and attitudes of some staff” and emphasized that institutional resources should be reviewed to maximize opportunities for meaningful interactions between staff and incarcerated women (p. 330). They recommended creating “regular and frequent opportunities for staff and people in prison to interact one-on-one,” including informal conversations and structured key worker sessions (p. 330). The authors also emphasized the need for broader cultural change, including recruiting and retaining staff who demonstrate compassion and understanding. Regarding training, they recommended expanding its content to include “skills training, increasing the focus on the development of perspective taking and empathy,” with incarcerated women participating in its development and delivery (p. 330). The authors further highlighted “the importance of protected, scheduled time” to facilitate consistent contact and supportive, trusting relationships (p. 330). These findings suggest that trauma-informed care requires more than staff education; it also depends on consistent, compassionate relationships and institutional practices that allow incarcerated individuals to feel safe, understood, and valued.
Translating Research into Practice
“Despite the emphasis on the delivery of BTI training within women’s prisons and in the Female Offender Strategy (Ministry of Justice, 2018), the findings from the current study appear to indicate that training alone may be insufficient to counter the negative behavior and attitudes of some staff. The perceived scarcity of staff time to support participants suggests that resources need to be reviewed in order that the capacity of staff to interact with people in prison can be maximized. The descriptions of staff demonstrating negative and uncaring attitudes toward participants, despite the existence of the training and the clear commitment of the women’s prison estate to deliver TIC, raises issues about the extent to which punitive prison cultures may prevail. Challenges remain around wider culture change required for women’s prisons to move closer toward the goal of delivering TIC. However, the findings from this study suggest that some small practical changes to the way staff and people in prison are actively encouraged and enabled to interact together could have substantial positive impacts. For example, the creation of regular and frequent opportunities for staff and people in prison to interact one-on-one, both informally and more formally (such as in key worker sessions). Feeling human appears central to the concept of TIC for people in prison, and therefore the benefit of their ability to engage in activities that achieve this should not be underestimated.
There is an urgent need to broaden the range of activity and effort designed to create the behavioral and attitudinal change required across the staff group working in women’s prisons, to develop a predominant culture of care and compassion toward individuals in prison. If training is to remain a key feature of HMPPS’s approach to developing TIC then the training model should be amended in collaboration with women in prison, to expand the contents; include skills training, increasing the focus on the development of perspective taking and empathy, as well as ensuring that training was co-delivered between staff and those in custody.
The participants’ accounts suggested that staff who demonstrated kindness; good listening skills, empathy and understanding appeared to embrace the aspects of their job which enabled them to provide compassionate care toward participants, and actively sought out time for individual interactions with them. None of the people interviewed felt that they required specific attention to their trauma. Attendance at a short-duration psychoeducational training course is unlikely to create sufficient opportunity to actively enable the development of such attitudes and skills if they did not exist already but might reinforce existing positive attitudes present in staff prior to the training. Ensuring that prison officers have supportive attitudes toward people in custody requires the proactive recruitment and retention of people who demonstrate caring attitudes and who perceive and embrace the role of a prison officer as being the provision of compassionate care to support the rehabilitation of incarcerated individuals. Additionally, recognizing the high level of need within the women’s prison population, which appeared to have been inadequately met by the limited staff resources available, HMPPS should consider ways to support staff to prevent them from being negatively impacted by their work (Tait, 2011), which could detrimentally impact their attitudes and behavior toward those in their care.
The positive response of participants at the prison where “key worker” arrangements were in place, highlights the importance of protected, scheduled time being made available for women in prison, to facilitate consistent individual contact with a member of staff with whom the person in prison can develop a supportive and trusting relationship. The roll-out of key working to all women’s prisons since the fieldwork for this research took place is a welcome development. Whilst this research provides evidence of the perceptions of people in prison about TIC, research is required to examine the perspectives and experiences of prison staff about the BTI training and the provision of TIC” (p. 330).


